Cila's first Tribal Council came down to a classic Survivor dilemma: do you vote out the player who cost you the challenge, or the one who's been scheming too loudly?

Jenna had been campaigning against Cirie since Day 1 — before the immunity challenge even happened. She pitched her name to Savannah, Joe, and Christian. When Cirie bombed the monkey's fist throw (roughly 15 agonizing minutes of the same failing technique), Jenna smelled blood. But the tribe smelled something else entirely: a player overplaying, hard, on Day 1.

Ozzy pushed aggressively to save Cirie, which raised eyebrows — especially with Joe, who'd been burned by a secret duo on Season 48 (Kyle and Kamilla) and was immediately suspicious of Ozzy and Cirie operating as a pair. Emily briefly floated Ozzy's name as an alternative target, and Rick acknowledged that several people might agree with it. But ultimately, the tribe unified: Jenna had to go.

The vote: Jenna 7, Cirie 1 (only Jenna voted for Cirie). Jenna offered a simple "good luck, guys" and refused Ozzy's hug on the way out. "First in, first out," she said at the torch snuff.