Worlds Apart Final Four

Clues

1. 1.The castaway who finished 2nd and Will Sims II are 11 years apart in age.
2. 2.Mike Holloway finished ahead of the 25-year-old.
3. 3.The 52-year-old is either Carolyn Rivera or the castaway who finished 1st.
4. 4.Neither Mike Holloway nor the 25-year-old is the castaway who finished 3rd.
5. 5.Neither the 52-year-old nor Rodney Lavoie Jr. is the castaway who finished 1st.